US Coast Guard announces seizure of two Cuba-bound fuel ships, including "Grace" on Sept. 5
The US Coast Guard announced on 2 October that it intercepted the cargo ship "Grace", carrying fuel bound for Cuba, on 5 September, and ABC News reports a second ship, the "Jaira Provider", was seized in June. The actions come amid the Trump administration's fuel blockade of Cuba.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
MixedThe US Coast Guard intercepted a roughly 300-foot (91-metre) vessel named "Grace" that was carrying fuel bound for Cuba, the New York Times reported on Friday 2 October, citing a Coast Guard statement. The Straits TimesRC “The 300-foot-long (91-meter-long) vessel named "Grace" was stopped in the Caribbean Sea between Cuba and Mexico on September 5” Read at The Straits Times ↗ ABC NewsLC “The U.S. Coast Guard announced on Friday the seizure of two ships bound for Cuba” Read at ABC News ↗ MixedThe ship was stopped on 5 September in the Caribbean Sea between Cuba and Mexico after, according to the Coast Guard, it used "dark fleet" or covert manoeuvres to evade authorities. The Straits TimesRC “after using "dark fleet" maneuvers in an attempt to evade authorities” Read at The Straits Times ↗ ABC NewsLC “after it was alleged to use covert operations to traverse the high seas” Read at ABC News ↗ LeftABC News reported that the Coast Guard carried out the Grace seizure together with Mexican authorities, and that the ship was taken to Progreso, Mexico, where a Mexican Navy inspection team confirmed large quantities of fuel in its ballast tanks, according to a Coast Guard news release. ABC NewsLC “seized on Sept. 5 by the Coast Guard and Mexican authorities in the Caribbean Sea”“where a Mexican Navy (MARINA) inspection team confirmed the presence of large quantities of fuel in the vessel’s ballast tanks” Read at ABC News ↗
RightThe Times, as relayed by Reuters, said it was unclear how much fuel the Grace carried, and that Coast Guard officials did not reveal how they knew the fuel was headed to Cuba, saying only that the assessment was based on intelligence. The Straits TimesRC “It was unclear how much fuel "Grace" was carrying, the Times said.”“said that assessment had been based on intelligence” Read at The Straits Times ↗ LeftABC News also reported that the Coast Guard announced the seizure of a second Cuba-bound ship, the "Jaira Provider", on 28 June; the Coast Guard said it carried more than 200,000 gallons of fuel, also stored in ballast tanks. ABC NewsLC “the "Jaira Provider," which they say was carrying more than 200,000 gallons of fuel when it was seized on June 28”“the fuel in the Jaria Provider was also stored in ballast tanks” Read at ABC News ↗ LeftABC News said it first obtained video showing Coast Guard agents in tactical gear boarding the Grace with guns drawn while a separate Coast Guard boat came alongside. ABC NewsLC “Video first obtained by ABC News shows Coast Guard agents equipped in tactical gear boarding the ship, guns drawn” Read at ABC News ↗
LeftCoast Guard Commandant Adm. Kevin Lunday said "The high seas are not a sanctuary for lawlessness" and that dark fleet actors "will not evade justice". ABC NewsLC “"The high seas are not a sanctuary for lawlessness," said Adm. Kevin Lunday, commandant of the Coast Guard.” Read at ABC News ↗ RightThe seizures come amid a US oil and fuel blockade of Cuba; Reuters says the Trump administration has openly stated its goal is to change Cuba's government, and that oil shipments from Venezuela and Mexico ended after the US ousted Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro in January. The Straits TimesRC “The Trump administration has openly stated that its goal is to change Cuba's government.”“Oil shipments from Cuba’s traditional suppliers, Venezuela and Mexico, ended abruptly after the US ousted Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro in January.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ MixedBoth reports describe a severe power crisis in Cuba; Reuters cites fuel shortages, blackouts and failing infrastructure, while ABC, citing US officials, lists prolonged outages affecting water supply, lighting, refrigeration and communications. The Straits TimesRC “fuel shortages and blackouts exacerbated by failing infrastructure” Read at The Straits Times ↗ ABC NewsLC “prolonged power outages impacting water supply, lighting, refrigeration and communications, according to U.S. officials” Read at ABC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- ABC News leads with the Coast Guard's announcement of two seizures, with exclusive video of an armed boarding and a quote from the Coast Guard commandant.
- Emphasis
- Enforcement detail: Mexican Navy inspection, ballast tanks, the second ship, 200,000 gallons, and the Coast Guard's law-and-justice language.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not note that how the Coast Guard knew the fuel was bound for Cuba was not disclosed; calls the cargo illegal without attribution.
- Charged language
- “illegally carrying”“lawlessness”
- For example
-
“two ships bound for Cuba that were illegally carrying thousands of gallons of diesel fuel” — ABC News
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Straits Times runs a short Reuters wire relaying the New York Times report, framing the interception within the Trump administration's oil embargo and its regime-change aim.
- Emphasis
- Context of the embargo's strain on Cuba, the end of Venezuelan and Mexican supplies, and uncertainty over the fuel quantity and intelligence basis.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No mention of the second ship, Mexican involvement or the Coast Guard commandant's statement.
- Charged language
- “crippling oil embargo”“dark fleet”
- For example
-
“the Trump administration's crippling oil embargo against the island nation continued” — The Straits Times
What every side reports
- The Coast Guard intercepted the 300-foot "Grace" on 5 September in the Caribbean between Cuba and Mexico.
- The ship was allegedly using covert or "dark fleet" tactics.
- The action took place amid the Trump administration's fuel blockade of Cuba, which has contributed to blackouts.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the ship was intercepted or seized, and how it is described
- Left
- ABC calls it a seizure of two ships that were "illegally carrying" fuel, with Mexican authorities involved.
- Right
- Reuters, via the Straits Times, says the Coast Guard "intercepted" a "cargo ship" and that the fuel amount is unclear.
United States Coast Guard organisation
Says it seized the Grace and the Jaira Provider for covert evasion tactics, with fuel hidden in ballast tanks, and vows to interdict such vessels; did not say how it knew the fuel was bound for Cuba beyond intelligence.
“The Coast Guard is bringing every capability to bear to interdict these vessels and uphold international law.” — ABC News
“said that assessment had been based on intelligence” — The Straits Times
Cuba place
Cuba is the destination and is under strain from the blockade; no Cuban official response is given in either report.
“has put the country under severe strain as it contends with fuel shortages and blackouts” — The Straits Times
Left1 article
-
US Coast Guard says it seized Cuba-bound ships with thousands of gallons of oil
Mixed Enforcement-focused account carrying Coast Guard statements and dramatic boarding video, largely adopting the Coast Guard's characterisation.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
US Coast Guard intercepts cargo boat carrying fuel bound for Cuba, NYT reports
Neutral Wire report relaying the NYT account, with context on the embargo and caveats about unknown fuel quantity.
- 2 Oct 14:43 First The Straits TimesRC US Coast Guard intercepts cargo boat carrying fuel bound for Cuba, NYT reports via Reuters
- 2 Oct 18:38 +3h 55m ABC NewsLC US Coast Guard says it seized Cuba-bound ships with thousands of gallons of oil
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.