US begins direct talks with Myanmar's military-installed government
Reuters reporting says the Trump administration has opened direct talks with Myanmar's military-installed government, starting with scam centres and an American detainee, and with rare earths also discussed. Rep. Gregory Meeks criticised the shift; the State Department defended engagement.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Trump administration has begun direct talks with Myanmar's military-installed government, according to US officials and others familiar with the outreach. This is a sharp reversal of Washington's efforts to isolate the generals after the 2021 coup. CNAN “The Trump administration has begun direct talks with Myanmar’s military-installed government, according to US officials and others familiar with the outreach” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “in a sharp reversal of Washington's efforts to isolate the country's generals after the 2021 coup” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Mixed · 2Michael Vance, the Assistant Secretary of State for Intelligence and Research, played a leading role. The outreach has focused on shutting down scam centres that target Americans but could lead to broader engagement, including on rare-earth minerals, according to seven current and former officials and others familiar with the shift. CNAN “played a leading role in the outreach, which has focused on shutting down scam centres that target Americans” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “according to seven current and former officials and others familiar with the policy shift” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Mixed · 2Vance joined talks with Myanmar leader Min Aung Hlaing in Naypyitaw on 15 and 16 September, the highest-level contact since the coup. The meeting aimed to secure the release of American businessman Adam Castillo and also opened the way to further engagement, four of the sources said. Vance's role had not been previously reported. CNAN “Vance joined talks with Myanmar leader Min Aung Hlaing in the capital Naypyitaw on Sep 15 and Sep 16.” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “Last month's meeting - the highest‑level contact since the coup” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗
Mixed · 2Castillo, a former head of the American Chamber of Commerce in Myanmar, was detained at Yangon airport on 11 June on what his supporters described as trumped-up charges. Sources said White House, National Security Council and State Department officials held back-channel negotiations for his release, and one said Myanmar asked only for an official engagement at the right level with the US government. Castillo declined to comment beyond crediting President Donald Trump for his release. The Jerusalem PostRC “was detained at Yangon airport on June 11 by Myanmar authorities on what his supporters have described as trumped-up charges” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ CNAN “to have an official engagement at the right level with the US government” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2The meeting built on a June meeting in Tokyo, also involving Vance, in which officials from the Treasury Department, the Department of Homeland Security and the Pentagon reportedly took part. It is unclear who represented Myanmar. Vance has also met the democratic opposition and ethnic armed groups fighting the military, five sources said, and two sources said the FBI has had direct contact with Myanmar's authorities on cyber scams. CNAN “The meeting builds on a June meeting between US and Myanmar officials in Tokyo also involving Vance, four people said.” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “Two people familiar with the matter said the FBI has had direct contact with Myanmar's authorities on cyber scams.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Mixed · 2Researchers say many scams run from militia-controlled areas, with some proceeds flowing to the military, which raises doubts about enforcement. US officials also discussed heavy rare earths but acknowledge obstacles: the deposits mainly lie in territory held by ethnic armies fighting the military, and China, the main importer, could see a US role as a challenge. CNAN “Researchers say many scams are run from areas under militia control, with some proceeds flowing to the military” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “the deposits mainly lie in territory held by ethnic armies fighting Myanmar's military government” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗
Mixed · 2Min Aung Hlaing, the former military chief, remains under US sanctions for human rights abuses, including the 2016-2017 killings and expulsions of Rohingya that Washington declared a genocide. Less than two weeks after Vance's visit, Myanmar's military bombed a crowded marketplace in Rakhine state, killing over 50 people, according to UN human rights officials. Min Aung Hlaing is seeking international legitimacy for his nominally civilian government. CNAN “remains under US sanctions for human rights abuses” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “killing over 50 people and injuring scores more, according to United Nations human rights officials” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Mixed · 2The State Department said it engages with all groups in Myanmar on issues affecting US interests and raises the need to end violence and release political prisoners. Spokesperson Tommy Pigott said: "You don't solve problems by ignoring them." Pigott declined to address Vance's role, saying the administration "operates as a team with the president as the lead." A spokesperson for the military-backed government did not respond to a request for comment. CNAN ““You don't solve problems by ignoring them. You solve problems by addressing them,” spokesperson Tommy Pigott said in a statement.” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “A spokesperson for the military-backed government did not respond to a request for comment.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Mixed · 2Critics object to both the policy and the process. Rep. Gregory Meeks, the top Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, called the shift "contrary to both our values and our interests" and said Secretary of State Marco Rubio was giving the regime greater legitimacy. Richard Betts of the Council on Foreign Relations noted that intelligence chiefs do not typically steer policy because of concerns about analytic independence. The Jerusalem PostRC “contrary to both our values and our interests” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ CNAN “Intelligence chiefs - such as Vance - do not typically steer policy because of concerns about compromising analytic independence.” Read at CNA ↗
Mixed · 2Under Joe Biden, the US froze Myanmar's assets at the New York Federal Reserve and sanctioned senior officers and military-linked businesses. Congress authorised non-lethal support for the opposition in 2022, but most of those programmes were cut in Trump's foreign-aid overhaul last year. Myanmar's government has hired lobbyists in Washington, including Roger Stone, who began consulting in April for DCI Group on behalf of the Ministry of Information, according to Foreign Agents Registration Act filings. CNAN “Most of those programs were cut during Trump’s foreign-aid overhaul last year” Read at CNA ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “In April, Roger Stone, a longtime Trump adviser, began consulting for DCI Group on behalf of Myanmar's Ministry of Information” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- CNA runs the Reuters report under a headline stressing a reversal of years of isolation, and adds ASEAN context.
- Emphasis
- The policy reversal, transactional diplomacy, and ASEAN's exclusion of Myanmar with the Five-Point Consensus.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Nothing material from the Reuters report is left out.
- Charged language
- “reversing years of isolation”
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Jerusalem Post carries the same Reuters text, credited to Reuters, under a headline about a reversal of isolation attempts after the coup. It adds subheads on the Castillo negotiations, the fraud crackdown and Meeks' criticism.
- Emphasis
- The same Reuters facts; the subheads highlight the detainee and the fight against fraud operations.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the ASEAN Five-Point Consensus background that CNA adds.
- Charged language
- “coup leader-turned-president”
- For example
-
“US begins direct talks with Myanmar in reversal of isolation attempts following military coup” — The Jerusalem Post
“Top Foreign Affairs Committee Democrat decries shift in Myanmar relations” — The Jerusalem Post
What every side reports
- The Trump administration has begun direct talks with Myanmar's military-installed government.
- Michael Vance joined talks with Min Aung Hlaing in Naypyitaw on 15-16 September, aimed at freeing Adam Castillo.
- Min Aung Hlaing remains under US sanctions.
- Rep. Gregory Meeks criticised the shift, while the State Department defended engagement.
Trump administration organisation
The State Department says it engages all groups in Myanmar on issues affecting US interests and presses for an end to violence and the release of political prisoners. It says the administration operates as a team with the president as the lead.
“The State Department said it engages with all groups in Myanmar on issues affecting US interests” — CNA
“operates as a team with the president as the lead” — CNA
Myanmar place
Myanmar's military-backed government did not respond to a request for comment. Min Aung Hlaing is seeking international legitimacy, and the government has hired lobbyists in Washington.
“A spokesperson for the military-backed government did not respond to a request for comment.” — The Jerusalem Post
“has hired lobbyists to press its case in Washington” — The Jerusalem Post
Myanmar scam centres topic
Shutting down scam hubs that defraud Americans is the main US aim, though researchers doubt Myanmar's leaders will enforce, since some proceeds flow to the military.
“A major focus of the US push is getting Myanmar's help in shuttering scam hubs” — CNA
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
CNAN ·
US opens direct talks with Myanmar's generals, reversing years of isolation
Neutral Reuters-based report presenting the talks as a policy reversal, with critics' and officials' views and added ASEAN background.
Right1 article
-
US begins direct talks with Myanmar in reversal of isolation attempts following military coup
Neutral Reuters copy credited to Reuters, with subheads; the same facts and sourcing as CNA.
- 8 Oct 06:36 First CNAN US opens direct talks with Myanmar's generals, reversing years of isolation
- 8 Oct 07:16 +40m The Jerusalem PostRC US begins direct talks with Myanmar in reversal of isolation attempts following military coup
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.