Utah warns of opioid-like kratom compounds in "cat's claw" products after four deaths
Utah health, poison center and agriculture officials said on Monday that four deaths are linked to potent semi-synthetic kratom compounds found in some herbal supplements, including products labelled "cat's claw". Details of the deaths have not been made public.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Utah health officials issued an urgent public health warning on Monday after four deaths were linked to "high-potency" and illegal chemical compounds found in herbal supplements. The IndependentLC “Utah health officials have issued an urgent public health warning following four deaths linked to “high-potency” and illegal chemical compounds found in herbal supplements.” Read at The Independent ↗ NBC NewsLC “Four deaths in Utah have been linked to potent semi-synthetic kratom compounds, state officials said Monday.” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 1The compounds are mitragynine pseudoindoxyl (MGPI) and dihydro-7-hydroxymitragynine (MGM-15), semi-synthetic derivatives of kratom that are illegal in Utah and that the Drug Enforcement Administration has recently classified as Schedule 1 drugs. NBC NewsLC “are illegal in the state and were recently classified by the Drug Enforcement Administration as Schedule 1 drugs” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 2Officials said the compounds turned up in certain herbal supplements, including kratom products and products labelled "cat's claw"; the Independent describes them as powerful opioids stronger than morphine. NBC NewsLC “the compounds were found in certain herbal supplements, including kratom products, as well as products labeled “cat’s claw.”” Read at NBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “These substances are stronger than morphine and addictive.” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 1Cat's claw, a South American vine used by some people for its anti-inflammatory properties, is generally considered safe; NBC News reports that testing in these cases found the products contained MGPI and MGM-15. NBC NewsLC “Experts say that cat’s claw, which comes from a South American vine, is generally safe.”“Cat’s claw is not a harmful supplement, but testing in these cases revealed it contained MPGI and MGM-15” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 2The warning said the products are often sold under brand names such as "Buzzers" and misleadingly labelled as containing cat's claw; labels often claim the product is legal and free of kratom while saying it is for adults 21 and over or produces strong psychoactive effects. NBC NewsLC ““often sold under brand names like ‘Buzzers’ and are misleadingly labeled as containing ‘cat’s claw’ or its scientific name Uncaria tomentosa.”” Read at NBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “The labels often claim the products are legal and free of kratom.” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1Dr Michael Moss, medical director of the Utah Poison Control Center, said: "No one should take these products, retailers should not sell them, and healthcare providers should be aware of potential for addiction, withdrawal, and overdose related to their use." NBC NewsLC ““No one should take these products, retailers should not sell them, and healthcare providers should be aware of potential for addiction, withdrawal, and overdose related to their use.”” Read at NBC News ↗
Left · 2The two outlets differ on the link to Buzzers: the Independent says Utah reported one death tied to a mislabelled Buzzers product in July, while NBC News says the warning does not directly link Buzzers products to the deaths. The IndependentLC “One death tied to a Buzzers product that had been mislabeled was reported by Utah in July.” Read at The Independent ↗ NBC NewsLC “(The warning does not directly link the Buzzers’ products to the deaths.)” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 2Exo Club, which makes Buzzers, did not immediately respond to requests for comment; NBC News reports its website says the product does not contain kratom but that it extracts an indole alkaloid from the cat's claw plant "to mirror the effects of popular kratom products". NBC NewsLC ““We extract an indole alkaloid from the Cat’s Claw plant to mirror the effects of popular kratom products,” the website reads.” Read at NBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “Exo Club, the manufacturer of Buzzers, did not immediately respond to a request for comment Tuesday.” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1Neither kratom nor cat's claw is approved by the Food and Drug Administration, yet both are sold in places such as convenience stores, smoke shops and gas stations; only pure, natural leaf kratom is legally sold in Utah. The IndependentLC “Neither are approved for use by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, but are still sold in convenience stores, smoke shops and gas stations.”“Only pure and natural leaf kratom products are legally sold in Utah.” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 2The warning follows the September deaths of two University of Mississippi students, 18-year-old Aidan Hamilton and 20-year-old Robert Strang, who were found with packaged kratom at separate scenes; it is unclear whether kratom contributed, but federal prosecutors said both deaths appear consistent with drug overdoses, and a store owner and his son have been charged with selling the kratom. The IndependentLC “The students were identified as 18-year-old Aidan Hamilton and 20-year-old Robert Strang.”“A store owner and his son have been charged with selling the kratom.” Read at The Independent ↗ NBC NewsLC “In Mississippi, investigators are looking into the deaths of two University of Mississippi students in September.” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 1Other states have issued similar warnings: Tennessee did so in September after its Bureau of Investigation found MGM-15 in cat's claw products, and Virginia's Blue Ridge Poison Center has received calls about cat's claw products causing opioid-like effects. NBC NewsLC “Tennessee issued its own warning in September after the state’s Bureau of Investigation found the synthetic kratom compound MGM-15 in cat’s claw products.” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 2On the scale of kratom harm, the Independent cites a CDC figure of a 1,200 percent rise in poison control calls about kratom from 2015 to 2025, while NBC News cites a CDC report of 233 deaths linked to kratom over the same period. The IndependentLC “Poison control centers across the U.S. have reported a 1,200 percent increase in calls about kratom from 2015 to 2025” Read at The Independent ↗ NBC NewsLC “233 deaths were linked to kratom from 2015 to 2025.” Read at NBC News ↗
Left · 2Regulation varies: the Independent lists Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Indiana, Louisiana, Tennessee, Vermont and Wisconsin as having banned kratom, while NBC News says it is banned in at least 10 states; the DEA has announced its intent to classify 7-OH as illicit but has not yet done so. The IndependentLC “Several states have taken action to ban the substance, including Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Indiana, Louisiana, Tennessee, Vermont and Wisconsin.” Read at The Independent ↗ NBC NewsLC “Kratom is banned in at least 10 states, and many others regulate it”“This summer, the DEA announced its intent to do so, but has not yet done so.” Read at NBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets lead with the Utah warning and place it in a national context of kratom risks; the Independent ties it to the Ole Miss deaths, NBC News stresses the semi-synthetic compounds and mislabelling.
- Emphasis
- Mislabelled cat's claw products, opioid-like potency, other states' warnings and federal regulatory status.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Independent omits the DEA Schedule 1 classification and that cat's claw itself is generally safe; NBC News gives the Mississippi deaths only brief mention and does not mention charges against the store owner and son.
- Charged language
- “urgent public health warning”“dangerous opioids”
- For example
-
“Utah health officials have issued an urgent public health warning following four deaths” — The Independent
““These cat’s claw products contain dangerous opioids derived from kratom,”” — NBC News
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Utah officials announced on Monday that four deaths are linked to potent kratom-derived compounds in herbal supplements.
- The products are labelled as cat's claw, sold under names like Buzzers, and contain MGPI and MGM-15.
- Neither kratom nor cat's claw is FDA-approved.
- Exo Club, maker of Buzzers, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
- Two University of Mississippi students were found dead in September with packaged kratom nearby.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Buzzers products are tied to a Utah death
- Left
- The Independent says Utah reported one death tied to a mislabelled Buzzers product in July; NBC News says the warning does not directly link Buzzers products to the deaths.
Utah place
Utah health, poison center and agriculture officials warn the public not to take the products, urge retailers not to sell them and healthcare providers to watch for addiction, withdrawal and overdose.
““No one should take these products, retailers should not sell them” — NBC News
University of Mississippi organisation
Two of its students were found dead in September with packaged kratom nearby; federal prosecutors say the deaths appear consistent with overdoses, and it is unclear whether kratom contributed.
“It is unclear whether kratom contributed to either death, but federal prosecutors said both fatalities appear consistent with drug overdoses.” — The Independent
UK and Ireland1 outlet
The Independent presents it as a US story, connecting Utah's warning to the Ole Miss deaths and US state bans.
“Several states have taken action to ban the substance” — The Independent
The Independent
North America1 outlet
NBC News gives the regulatory and scientific detail, including DEA scheduling and other states' warnings.
“Several other states have also recently issued warnings about products labeled to be cat’s claw” — NBC News
NBC News
Left2 articles
-
Utah officials warn of fatal overdoses involving kratom and cat’s claw after Ole Miss deaths
Alarmist Frames the Utah warning as an urgent alert linked to the Ole Miss student deaths, with national kratom statistics and a list of state bans.

-
Semi-synthetic kratom products linked to four deaths in Utah, state officials say
Neutral Explains the semi-synthetic compounds, mislabelling and regulatory status in detail, noting the warning does not directly link Buzzers to the deaths and that cat's claw itself is safe.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 6 Oct 14:43 First The IndependentLC Utah officials warn of fatal overdoses involving kratom and cat’s claw after Ole Miss deaths
- 6 Oct 19:44 +5h NBC NewsLC Semi-synthetic kratom products linked to four deaths in Utah, state officials say
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.