Vance tasked with winning back young male voters ahead of midterms; allies divided on whether he can
Per a Politico report relayed by two left-leaning outlets, the White House and Republicans are counting on Vice President JD Vance to win back young men before the November midterms, while some allies doubt he can, citing the Iran war and gas prices.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Vice President JD Vance is trying to win back young men who swung toward President Donald Trump in 2024, and to persuade them to vote Republican in the November midterms, according to a Politico report relayed by The Independent and Raw Story. The IndependentLC “Vice President JD Vance is trying to win back the young, white men who helped propel President Donald Trump back to power in the 2024 presidential election” Read at The Independent ↗ Raw StoryL “The White House and Republicans are counting on Vice President JD Vance to keep young men in the MAGA fold ahead of the midterms” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Vance has appeared on manosphere podcasts including Joe Rogan and Jack Posobiec's, and has said the administration is committed to tackling "institutionalized anti-white, anti-male discrimination in this country". The IndependentLC “appearing on manosphere podcasts like Joe Rogan and Jack Posobiec”“institutionalized anti-white, anti-male discrimination in this country” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1Trump won 18-24-year-old men by 3 points in 2024, according to CNN exit polling cited by Politico, but his net favourability with the group has fallen to minus 17 in a recent Cygnal poll. The IndependentLC “Trump won 18-24-year-old men by 3 points, according to Politico, citing CNN exit polling data.”“net favorability rating with the demographic has plummeted to minus 17” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 2Both outlets say frustration over the Iran war and the cost of living, including high gas prices, is eroding support among young men. Raw StoryL “have grown frustrated over the Iran war” Read at Raw Story ↗ The IndependentLC “which has triggered high gas prices and has no end in sight” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 2Allies are upbeat: an RNC official said party data shows persuadable young men lean Republican over Democrat, RNC press secretary Natalie Baldassare called Vance "the perfect messenger", and Posobiec said he is "the most effective messenger to young voters" after interviewing him on Air Force Two. The IndependentLC “young men who are persuadable voters are more likely to lean Republican than Democrat”“Vice President Vance is the perfect messenger for young men” Read at The Independent ↗ Raw StoryL “There's no question that JD is the most effective messenger to young voters” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Turning Point USA spokesman Andrew Kolvet said Vance speaks to young men without talking down to them. The IndependentLC “JD has a way of doing it without speaking down to them” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 2Others are doubtful: an anonymous person close to the White House said young men may be "a lost cause" in the midterms, a former Trump campaign official said there is no consensus Vance is the right person, and a conservative commentator said his approach concedes Trump's foreign policy is unpopular. The IndependentLC “young men might be “a lost cause” in the midterms”“I don’t think there’s any kind of consensus” Read at The Independent ↗ Raw StoryL “even administration allies are skeptical Vance "can stanch the bleeding,"” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Raw Story adds that allies see Vance's success as potentially decisive in close Senate races in youthful states like Alaska and Texas, and that he is laying groundwork for a possible presidential run; Rachel Bovard of the Conservative Partnership Institute, a longtime ally, noted the burden of speaking to young people as a peer and a potential next president. Raw StoryL “could decide close Senate races in states like Alaska and Texas”“JD has the burden of speaking to them as both their age and also potentially their next president” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2Vance, who has to balance backing Trump on the Iran war with his own opposition to overseas conflicts, said at the Dallas midterm convention that he is not asking for agreement on every policy, and in April acknowledged many young voters dislike the administration's Middle East policy. The IndependentLC “I’m not asking anybody to agree on every single policy of the administration” Read at The Independent ↗ Raw StoryL “I recognize that a lot of young voters don’t love the policy that we have in the Middle East, okay?” Read at Raw Story ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both relay Politico's report on Vance's outreach to young men and the doubts within the GOP; The Independent leads on the 'plan' and the 'white-male manosphere', Raw Story on insider scepticism.
- Emphasis
- Iran war, gas prices, Trump's slump with Gen Z, and divided allies.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither adds independent reporting beyond Politico, and no right or centre outlets covered it.
- Charged language
- “manosphere”“stanch the bleeding”“mad”
- For example
-
“JD Vance has a plan to bring the white-male manosphere back to Trump and MAGA” — The Independent
“Insiders skeptical JD Vance 'can stanch the bleeding' as 'mad' MAGA men leave: report” — Raw Story
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Both outlets rely on a Politico report.
- Young men swung toward Trump in 2024 but are now frustrated over the Iran war and costs.
- Vance is seen by allies as a leading messenger to young men, while some insiders doubt he can succeed.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Vance can win back young men
- Left
- Both left outlets relay allies' confidence (Posobiec, RNC, Kolvet) alongside insiders' doubts that the group is a 'lost cause'; Raw Story headlines the scepticism, The Independent headlines Vance's plan.
JD Vance person
Vance acknowledges young voters' frustration with Middle East policy and asks supporters to focus on the contrast with 'radicals' and the administration's achievements.
“I recognize that a lot of young voters don’t love the policy that we have in the Middle East, okay?” — Raw Story
“recognize the contrast with the radicals” — The Independent
Left2 articles
-
JD Vance has a plan to bring the white-male manosphere back to Trump and MAGA
Mixed Balanced relay of Politico with allies' praise and critics' doubts, framed around Vance's 'plan' for the manosphere.

-
Insiders skeptical JD Vance 'can stanch the bleeding' as 'mad' MAGA men leave: report
Critical Emphasises insider scepticism that Vance can stem losses among angry MAGA men.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 8 Oct 16:21 First The IndependentLC JD Vance has a plan to bring the white-male manosphere back to Trump and MAGA
- 8 Oct 16:22 +1m Raw StoryL Insiders skeptical JD Vance 'can stanch the bleeding' as 'mad' MAGA men leave: report
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.