Which? warns pension drawdown savers who stay with one provider may pay far higher fees
Consumer group Which? says half of pension drawdown customers stay with their existing provider and could pay tens of thousands of pounds more in fees than with the cheapest option. Industry figures say cost should not be judged in isolation.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Consumer group Which? has warned that pension savers who stay with their existing provider when they move into drawdown could pay thousands, or tens of thousands, of pounds more in fees than they need to. Evening StandardN “Brand loyalty could cost some people tens of thousands of pounds over their retirement, Which? said.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MirrorL “Savers could be paying tens of thousands in extra fees by staying with their pension provider when they start accessing their retirement pot” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Centre · 1Drawdown lets savers take money from a pension pot while the rest stays invested and can continue to grow, choosing how much and how often to withdraw. Evening StandardN “This option allows savers who have reached the stage when they are taking an income from their pension to choose how much and how often they want to withdraw, while the rest of the money remains invested.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1Which? analysed the annual fees of 18 drawdown providers across different pot sizes, and surveyed more than 1,700 drawdown customers aged 55 and over in September. Evening StandardN “Which? analysed the annual fees payable with 18 drawdown providers, using different pension pot sizes.”“a survey of more than 1,700 drawdown customers aged 55 and over in September” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Mixed · 2Half (50%) of those surveyed had stayed with their existing pension provider when setting up drawdown rather than shopping around. Evening StandardN “half (50%) had remained with their existing pension provider, rather than shopping around.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MirrorL “Which? found half of savers stick with their existing pension provider when they switch to a drawdown route” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 1For the largest pot analysed, £750,000, the Daily Mirror reports annual fees ranged from £1,740 at the cheapest provider to £6,638 at the most expensive, close to four times as much. Daily MirrorL “The lowest fee levied by providers work out at £1,740 a year, while the highest was £6,638 - close to four times as much.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2Over 10 years, assuming 5% annual investment growth, a customer with that pot would pay more than £60,000 extra with the most expensive provider; the Mirror gives the figure as £61,877. Evening StandardN “a drawdown customer could potentially pay more than £60,000 more in fees with the most expensive option versus the cheapest.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MirrorL “a drawdown customer would pay £61,877 more in fees with the most expensive provider versus the cheapest.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Left · 1For a £250,000 pot, the Mirror says fees ranged from £780 to £2,275 a year, a gap of £18,658 over a decade. Daily MirrorL “For a pot worth £250,000, Which? found fees ranged from £780 a year to £2,275. Over a decade, that would mean paying £18,658 more than with the cheapest option.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2Paul Davies, a pensions expert at Which?, said "blind brand loyalty could quietly cost them tens of thousands of pounds" and that "just a few hours spent comparing providers today could preserve a substantial chunk of your nest egg". Evening StandardN “blind brand loyalty could quietly cost them tens of thousands of pounds over their retirement.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MirrorL “Just a few hours spent comparing providers today could preserve a substantial chunk of your nest egg for the years ahead.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 1The Mirror adds that platform fees are not the only cost: many providers require savers to take financial advice at some point, and some serve only advised customers, which Which? says can be costly. Daily MirrorL “Many providers require savers to get financial advice at some point in the process, and some are only available to advised customers.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Centre · 1Industry voices quoted by the Evening Standard agreed savers should shop around but cautioned against judging on fees alone, pointing to investment performance, features and changing income needs. Evening StandardN “Investment performance, withdrawal levels and changing income needs can all play a part in how long a pot lasts.”“comparing on cost alone only gives half the picture.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1M&G's spokesperson said cost alone does not show whether a pension delivers value, and PensionBee's Becky O'Connor said plans are hard to compare because of differing charging structures and services. Evening StandardN “Not all pensions are the same, and cost alone doesn’t tell you whether a pension is delivering value.”“it can be very difficult to compare plans from different providers due to different charging structures and services.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Consumer-warning story built around Which?'s "loyalty trap" and the size of the fee gaps.
- Emphasis
- Specific fee figures for £750,000 and £250,000 pots, and the cost of financial advice.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Industry responses (ABI, M&G, PensionBee, Skipton) and the 18-provider scope of the analysis.
- Charged language
- “loyalty trap”“hefty”
- For example
-
“even though they could be paying higher fees through what it calls a “loyalty trap”.” — Daily Mirror
“The largest typical pension pot Which? analysed was worth a hefty £750,000.” — Daily Mirror
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Reports Which?'s warning of a "loyalty penalty", then balances it with several industry responses.
- Emphasis
- Quotes from the ABI, M&G, PensionBee and Skipton Building Society that cost is only part of value.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The £250,000 pot figures, the £1,740–£6,638 annual fee range and the point about advice costs.
- Charged language
- “loyalty penalty”“blind brand loyalty”
- For example
-
“Pension savers could risk paying a “loyalty penalty” by allowing their retirement pots to be eroded through fees costing thousands of pounds more than they may need to pay, Which? is warning.” — Evening Standard
“Savers should be looking at the whole picture, rather than focusing on one number alone.” — Evening Standard
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Which? surveyed more than 1,700 drawdown customers and found half stayed with their existing provider.
- Which? says the most expensive provider could cost more than £60,000 extra over 10 years on a £750,000 pot, assuming 5% annual growth.
- Paul Davies of Which? urged savers to shop around.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether fees are the right measure for choosing a drawdown provider
- Left
- The Mirror presents the fee gaps as a "loyalty trap" and does not carry industry rebuttals.
- Centre
- The Standard gives space to PensionBee, Skipton Building Society, the ABI and M&G, who say fees shouldn't be viewed in isolation from performance and features.
Pension drawdown topic
Drawdown keeps the remaining pot invested while savers withdraw income; Which? says fees vary widely across providers, while industry voices say charges must be weighed against performance and features.
“This option allows savers who have reached the stage when they are taking an income from their pension to choose how much and how often they want to withdraw, while the rest of the money remains invested.” — Evening Standard
“Each provider will have an individual investment approach and offer different drawdown options to their customers” — Evening Standard
Left1 article
-
'Loyalty trap' could be costing savers tens of thousands in extra fees
Sympathetic Consumer-warning angle on savers losing tens of thousands, with detailed fee figures and little industry reply.

Centre1 article
-
Retirees warned that pension ‘loyalty penalty’ could cost thousands of pounds
Neutral Reports Which?'s warning and balances it with multiple industry responses urging a whole-picture view.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 17 Nov 00:01 First Evening StandardN Retirees warned that pension ‘loyalty penalty’ could cost thousands of pounds
- 17 Nov 00:03 +2m Daily MirrorL 'Loyalty trap' could be costing savers tens of thousands in extra fees
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…