White House task force releases records on FBI tracking of Susie Wiles' calls in Jack Smith probe
Records released Monday by the White House Government Transparency Task Force show FBI investigators working with Jack Smith's team logged Susie Wiles' phone contacts in 2023 during the classified documents probe. The two right-leaning outlets covering it differ on whether this was a "tap" or call metadata.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2The White House Government Transparency Task Force released declassified records on Monday 5 October 2026 showing that investigators in Jack Smith's classified documents inquiry tracked the phone contacts of Susie Wiles, who ran Trump's 2024 campaign and is now White House chief of staff. Washington ExaminerR “according to records released Monday by the White House Government Transparency Task Force” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ New York PostR “according to documents released Monday by the White House” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 2The task force is led by Just the News founder John Solomon. The monitoring was part of an investigation code-named "Plasmic Echo". Washington ExaminerR “The task force, led by Just the News founder John Solomon” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ New York PostR “was part of a secret probe titled “Plasmic Echo.”” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The Washington Examiner reports that investigators obtained phone metadata through a pen register, which records numbers and call timing rather than content, so the records do not show what Wiles discussed. It says they examined communications involving at least five journalists, 21 defence attorneys and several political advisers. Washington ExaminerR “Investigators obtained phone metadata through a pen register, a surveillance tool that records information such as numbers contacted and the timing of calls, rather than the contents of conversations.”“at least five journalists, 21 defense attorneys, and several political advisers” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Right · 1The New York Post describes the same activity as the FBI having "tapped" Wiles' cell phone. Its account of the logs says they cover calls between February and May 2023 with nearly two dozen Trump-linked lawyers, plus campaign aides, advisers and journalists, with Trump's calls noted via a "vanity number". Most identities are redacted, but the Post says current FBI Director Kash Patel, then out of government, is named. New York PostR “monitored Wiles’ cell phone between February and May 2023 for calls with nearly two dozen lawyers connected with Trump”“all of whose identities are redacted except that of current FBI Director Kash Patel” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 2Examples cited include a 10 March 2023 FBI memo with three pages of Wiles' contacts, a call logged on 19 May 2023 from Trump's number lasting 16 minutes 11 seconds, and calls from reporters at outlets including the Washington Post, Politico, CNN, Just the News and ABC News. The Post says Wiles received 39 calls on 9 March 2023. Washington ExaminerR “The task force cited a March 10, 2023, FBI memo containing three pages of Wiles’s phone contacts.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ New York PostR ““2:05 pm The FPOTUS Vanity Number called WILES for 16 minutes and 11 seconds.””“On March 9, 2023, for example, Wiles made or received 39 calls” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The Examiner adds that the release included preservation requests sent on 3 February 2023 to Google, Microsoft, MSN and Yahoo for Wiles' email information, and an FBI email asking staff to check the social media of Robert O'Brien, Trump's former national security adviser, two days before Smith's team subpoenaed him. Washington ExaminerR “preservation requests sent to Google, Microsoft, MSN, and Yahoo on Feb. 3, 2023”“Two days later, Smith’s team subpoenaed O’Brien as part of the investigation into Trump.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Right · 1The Post reports that the records also show the FBI tracing Melania and Barron Trump's travel in May 2022 while planning the best time to search Mar-a-Lago, so that any warrant would be served after the former president left. The raid took place on 8 August 2022 and included Trump's office and the first couple's bedrooms. New York PostR ““Finalize FBI understanding of FPOTUS/FLOTUS/minor son’s travel (type of aircraft and specifictimeline),””“The FBI ultimately carried out the raid on August 8, 2022, which included searches of Trump’s office and both of the first couple’s bedrooms.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 2Both outlets say then-FBI Director Christopher Wray recommended approval of the sensitive investigation, writing "I recommend you approve" (the Post quotes a typo, "recomend"). They differ on details: the Examiner dates the memo to March 2022 and says Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco signed it, while the Post dates it to May 2022 and says Attorney General Merrick Garland signed off. Washington ExaminerR ““I recommend you approve,” Monaco wrote at the end of the March 2022 memo.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ New York PostR “Then-Attorney General Merrick Garland signed off the wiretaps on the advice of then-FBI Director Christopher Wray, who sent Garland a memo in May 2022” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The Examiner also highlights a previously unreported 3 November 2023 meeting between the FBI, Smith's staff and former CIA Director John Brennan at CIA headquarters about possible expert testimony. It notes that the memo says no documents were shown and Brennan took no notes, and that Smith told Sen. Chuck Grassley a week earlier "I've never met John Brennan." Washington ExaminerR “a never-before-reported Nov. 3, 2023, meeting with former CIA Director John Brennan at CIA headquarters in McLean, Virginia”“Smith gave an indirect response, saying, “I’ve never met John Brennan.”” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Right · 2The White House called the surveillance abuse. Spokesperson Lauren Bis said it was "a disgraceful abuse of government power" and that "those responsible must be held accountable." An administration official quoted by the Examiner said investigators showed inappropriate interest in protected political and journalistic activity. No response from Smith or the former FBI and Justice Department officials appears in either article. New York PostR ““Jack Smith’s surveillance operation was a disgraceful abuse of government power,” White House spokesperson Lauren Bis said in a statement.” Read at New York Post ↗ Washington ExaminerR “The White House portrayed those inquiries as inappropriate scrutiny of protected political and journalistic activity.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Right · 1Context: the documents case against Trump was dismissed in July 2024 by a federal judge who found Smith had been unlawfully appointed by Garland, according to the Post. New York PostR “The documents case against Trump was thrown out in July 2024 by a federal judge who found Smith had been unlawfully appointed by Garland.” Read at New York Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right3 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the release as evidence of improper Biden-era surveillance by Jack Smith's team and the FBI, relying largely on the task force's account of the documents. The Examiner leads on Wiles' contacts with lawyers and journalists; the Post leads on the Trump family's travel and a 'tapped' phone.
- Emphasis
- Examiner: journalist and lawyer contacts, O'Brien social media check, the Brennan meeting and Smith's Senate testimony. Post: Melania and Barron Trump's travel, call-log detail, and the White House statement calling it abuse.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither includes a response from Smith, the FBI or former Justice Department officials. The Examiner's own caveat that metadata does not show conversation content is not carried by the Post, which uses 'tapped' and 'wiretaps'.
- Charged language
- “Biden FBI”“tapped”“disgraceful abuse of government power”“weaponization of law enforcement”“eye-raising memo”“since-discredited Russia investigation”
- For example
-
“The records, therefore, do not establish what Wiles and her contacts discussed.” — Washington Examiner
“Spying on political opponents is weaponization of law enforcement, plain and simple.” — New York Post
What every side reports
- The White House Government Transparency Task Force released the records on Monday 5 October 2026.
- The records concern the 'Plasmic Echo' investigation and logs of Susie Wiles' phone contacts with Trump's lawyers, advisers and journalists in early 2023.
- Many names in the records are redacted.
- Christopher Wray recommended approval of the sensitive investigation.
Where accounts differ
-
Nature of the monitoring of Wiles' phone
- Right
- The Washington Examiner stresses a pen register capturing metadata only, not call content; the New York Post says the FBI 'tapped' her phone and refers to 'wiretaps', while also quoting logs of call times and durations.
-
Date and approving official of the Wray memo
- Right
- The Examiner says March 2022 and that Monaco signed; the Post says May 2022 and that Garland signed off.
White House Government Transparency Task Force organisation
Released declassified FBI and Justice Department records showing, in its account, that investigators examined Wiles' communications with lawyers, journalists and advisers.
“revealed recently declassified records showing investigators from the Biden administration-era inquiry examined communications” — Washington Examiner
Susie Wiles person
Wiles is the subject of the tracked calls; neither article quotes her.
“Wiles at the time was running Trump’s political operation as he prepared for the 2024 election.” — New York Post
Jack Smith person
Smith appears only through the Examiner's account of his Senate testimony that he had 'never met John Brennan'; neither article carries a response to the release.
“Smith gave an indirect response, saying, “I’ve never met John Brennan.”” — Washington Examiner
John Solomon person
Solomon leads the task force that released the records.
“The task force, led by Just the News founder John Solomon” — Washington Examiner
Melania Trump person
Melania Trump and son Barron's travel was reportedly traced by the FBI while planning the Mar-a-Lago search; she is not quoted.
“The FBI monitored Melania and Barron Trump’s travel” — New York Post
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right3 articles
-
Jack Smith team tracked Susie Wiles calls and kept tabs on Trump lawyers, records show
Critical Presents the records as showing Smith's team scrutinising Trump allies, lawyers and reporters, while noting the data was metadata only.

-
Alarmist Frames the release as Biden-era FBI surveillance of the Trump family and Wiles, closing with the White House's call for accountability.

-

- 5 Oct 21:05 First Washington ExaminerR Jack Smith team tracked Susie Wiles calls and kept tabs on Trump lawyers, records show
- 5 Oct 21:58 +53m New York PostR Biden FBI tracked Melania and Barron Trump’s travel — and even tapped Susie Wiles phone, documents show
- 5 Oct 22:39 +1h 35m Fox NewsR Biden-era FBI tracked Trump family travel and Wiles’ calls with lawyers in secret probe: docs
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.