Woman accused of posing as substitute teacher at Milwaukee's Rufus King High School
Amy Jones, 23, is charged with impersonating a public employee and exposing children to harmful descriptions after allegedly posing as a substitute at Rufus King International High School on September 24. Her lawyers cite bipolar disorder and a medication problem; a preliminary hearing is set for October 20.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Amy Jones, 23, is accused of going to her former school, Rufus King International High School in Milwaukee, on September 24 and posing as a substitute teacher, according to Milwaukee County officials. The IndependentLC “went to her alma mater on September 24 under the guise of a substitute teacher” Read at The Independent ↗ MetroLC “after an incident at Rufus King International High School on September 24” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1A criminal complaint, as reported by local outlet WISN, says students told a school resource officer that she used profane language, racial slurs, sexually derogatory statements and organised students by race and gender. The Independent says she spent nearly three class periods doing this before she was escorted out. The IndependentLC “using profane language, racial slurs, sexually derogatory statements and organizing students by race and gender in class”“spent nearly three classroom periods berating and cursing at the students” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 2A 16-year-old boy told authorities that she called one student "fat boy", asked another if she wanted to be a stripper or a hooker, and told two white students they were the type to start school shootings. Fox6 News Milwaukee reported that she also asked whether students had a vape or weed. The IndependentLC “they were the type of people to start school shootings” Read at The Independent ↗ MetroLC “asked if any of the students had a vape or marijuana” Read at Metro ↗
Left · 1Metro adds that Jones allegedly scouted the school for a week, got past security by blending in with students, and went to a classroom set up by another teacher, who stayed with her for 20 minutes. After that teacher left, she allegedly played loud rap music and bragged about being fine with going to jail. MetroLC “scouted the premises for a week before carrying out the stunt”“playing loud rap music and bragging about being OK with going to jail” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1Principal Doreen Badillo told authorities that eight teachers had called in sick that day and only seven positions were filled, so she believed Jones "got lucky". Police escorted Jones out after the principal learned of the situation. The IndependentLC “eight teachers called in sick that day and only seven positions were filled”“Jones was escorted from the school by police after the principal, Doreen Badillo, became aware” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 2Police say Jones told them she went to the school "because she was bored", that she "hates kids" and that she "just wanted to f*** around". The IndependentLC “because she was bored” Read at The Independent ↗ MetroLC “just wanted to f*** around” Read at Metro ↗
Left · 2Jones faces six felony charges: one count of impersonating a public employee and five counts of exposing a child to harmful descriptions. The maximum sentence is 21 years if she is convicted. Jail records show she was taken into custody on a Thursday, and her preliminary hearing is set for October 20. The IndependentLC “six felony charges, including one count of impersonating a public employee and five counts of exposing a child to harmful descriptions” Read at The Independent ↗ MetroLC “Jones is scheduled for a preliminary court hearing on October 20” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 2Her defence team has said she is managing bipolar disorder and had a problem with her medication on the day of the incident. The IndependentLC “managing bipolar disorder and had a problem with her medication delivery” Read at The Independent ↗ MetroLC “she was experiencing issues with her medication on the day of the alleged incident” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1In statements to the school community, Badillo said Jones went through the school's safety scan but that the school office "did not follow proper district protocol in validating the individual as a substitute teacher". A later statement, sent October 5, said Jones was a former student recognised by staff and not a substitute teacher. It said police school resource officers and the district's Title IX coordinator were notified, and that Milwaukee Public Schools is running its own investigation. MetroLC “did not follow proper district protocol in validating the individual as a substitute teacher”“The district’s Title IX coordinator was also notified.” Read at Metro ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both UK outlets lead with the allegation that Jones posed as a substitute teacher because she "hates kids", and rely on the criminal complaint as reported by US local outlets. Their headlines stress her stated motive. Metro's is in scare quotes, and the Independent's says she went in 'just to' berate teens.
- Emphasis
- The specific insults and remarks quoted from the complaint, her reported statement to police, the charges and the 21-year maximum. Metro adds the security lapse and the district's statements.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither has comment from Jones or her lawyers beyond the bipolar and medication claim. The Independent says it has asked the school district for comment. The Independent leaves out the security lapse and the district's protocol statement.
- Charged language
- “mayhem”“stunt”“faked being a substitute teacher”
- For example
-
“Woman faked being a substitute teacher just to go into class and berate the teens” — The Independent
“causing mayhem in a class full of students” — Metro
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Amy Jones, 23, is accused of posing as a substitute teacher at Rufus King International High School in Milwaukee on September 24.
- She faces one count of impersonating a public employee and five counts of exposing a child to harmful descriptions, with a maximum of 21 years in prison.
- Her lawyers say she has bipolar disorder and had medication problems that day.
- A preliminary hearing is scheduled for October 20.
- Milwaukee Public Schools is conducting its own investigation.
Where accounts differ
-
How Jones got into the classroom
- Left
- The Independent quotes the principal saying Jones "got lucky" because of the substitute shortage. Metro adds that she scouted the school for a week and blended in with students, and quotes the principal saying the school office did not follow district protocol in validating her.
Amy Jones person
Authorities allege she posed as a substitute and said she was bored and hates kids. Her defence says she has bipolar disorder and had a medication problem that day.
“Her defense team has argued that she is managing bipolar disorder” — The Independent
“Her lawyers have said she suffers from bipolar disorder” — Metro
Left2 articles
-
Woman faked being a substitute teacher just to go into class and berate the teens
Mixed Leads with a wry take on the motive, then gives a detailed account from the complaint, along with the charges and the defence's mental-health explanation.

-
MetroLC ·
Woman ‘posed as substitute teacher to insult students because she hates kids’
Mixed Rewrites the Independent's account with added detail on scouting, security and the district's statements. Uses sensational wording such as "mayhem" and "stunt".

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 6 Oct 21:17 First The IndependentLC Woman faked being a substitute teacher just to go into class and berate the teens
- 7 Oct 15:43 +18h 26m MetroLC Woman ‘posed as substitute teacher to insult students because she hates kids’
- 7 Oct 16:35 +19h 18m New York PostR Bipolar woman posed as substitute teacher to call white students ‘motherf–kers’
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
