Workers who built US consulate in Milan sign record €31m settlement deals over alleged labor abuses
Foreign workers, mostly Indian, who built the new US consulate in Milan signed agreements averaging €45,000 each from a €31 million settlement with Caddell Construction. Prosecutors call it the largest settlement for labor exploitation in Europe; Caddell does not admit liability.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Foreign workers building the new US consulate compound in Milan signed agreements at a Milan hotel on Wednesday 7 October, securing payouts averaging €45,000 ($50,400) each for alleged labor abuses while working for an American construction company. Arab NewsRC “Foreign workers building the vast new US consulate compound in Milan signed agreements at a Milan hotel Wednesday securing payouts averaging 45,000 euros ($50,400) each” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN “Foreign workers building the vast new US consulate compound in Milan signed agreements at a Milan hotel Wednesday securing payouts averaging €45,000 (US$50,400) each” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Mixed · 2The payouts come from a €31 million (nearly $35 million) settlement agreed last month with Alabama-based Caddell Construction, which prosecutors say is the largest settlement ever for labor exploitation in Europe. Arab NewsRC “Prosecutors say it is the largest settlement ever for labor exploitation in Europe.” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN “settlement agreed last month with Alabama-based Caddell Construction” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Mixed · 2The signings began Tuesday; 115 workers had signed over two days, with the process continuing the following week. In all, nearly 480 workers can expect payouts: about 300 still on the site, another 100 elsewhere in Italy and the rest in their home countries. Arab NewsRC “Over two days, 115 workers signed the deals, with the procedure continuing next week.” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN “In all, nearly 480 workers can expect payouts - some 300 still working on the site, another 100 elsewhere in Italy and the rest in their home countries.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗
Mixed · 2The highest individual payout is nearly €90,000 (about $101,000), according to Francesco Brigatti, the court-appointed administrator working to return the site to legality. Payouts combine unpaid overtime, reimbursement of housing money illegally deducted from pay, and damages sought by investigating Prosecutor Paolo Storari; Brigatti said the damages alone equal 60–70 percent of the overtime total, well above the 10–30 percent he called customary. Arab NewsRC “with the highest reaching nearly 90,000 euros (nearly $101,000), said Francesco Brigatti” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN ““The damages component alone amounts to 60–70 per cent of the overtime total,” Brigatti said” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Mixed · 2Each worker signed a document, seen by the Associated Press, agreeing not to discredit Caddell or disclose individual payments, while Caddell stated that the settlement was not an admission of liability. Payments are due within 30 days of signing, and the settlement also gives workers permits to work in Italy beyond the Caddell site. Arab NewsRC “Caddell said in the document that the settlement was not an admission of liability. Individual payments are to be made within 30 days of the signing.” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN “Under the deal, the workers are also getting permits to work in Italy even off the Caddell site.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Mixed · 2Prosecutors allege workers were paid less than $2 an hour, illegally docked money for housing, and denied overtime for working up to 10 hours a day, six days a week, as well as threatened and denied proper medical care after injuries. Most came from India, with others from Nigeria, Kenya and Bangladesh; Indian workers reported paying recruiters €5,000 ($5,600), but the settlement does not directly address abuses in India, where prosecutors could not investigate. Arab NewsRC “Prosecutors say workers were paid less than $2 an hour, were illegally docked money for housing and denied overtime for working up to 10 hours a day, six days a week.” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN “the settlement did not directly address abuses in India, where prosecutors could not investigate, officials said.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗
Mixed · 2The investigation against Caddell remains open pending the payouts, expected to be completed by February, and two managers under investigation for extortion and facilitating illegal immigration remain under house arrest. The settlement also includes about €11.2 million ($12.5 million) for Italy's social security and workplace injury insurance. Arab NewsRC “Two managers under investigation for extortion and facilitating illegal immigration remain under house arrest.” Read at Arab News ↗ South China Morning PostN “Caddell’s settlement includes about €11.2 million (US$12.5 million) for Italy’s social security coffers and workplace injury insurance.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Centre · 1Caddell, a major contractor for US embassies and consulates, said it continues to cooperate in good faith with authorities and is focused on the well-being of people on the project. The US State Department said it is investigating the prosecutors' allegations, is working with Italian law enforcement and has “zero tolerance for illegal activity”. South China Morning PostN ““Caddell continues to cooperate in good faith with the appropriate authorities throughout this process, and we remain focused on the care and well-being of the people working on an important project,” the company said Wednesday.”““The US government has zero tolerance for illegal activity,” it said.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Right · 1Dilip Ram, a 43-year-old mason from Bihar, India, said the money would greatly help his family of five and that conditions had improved. Trifone Radogna of the Feneal Uil construction union said unions were initially denied access to the site on an erroneous claim of diplomatic status, and that his union had never encountered a labor-exploitation system on this scale. Arab NewsRC “Dilip Ram, a 43-year-old mason from India, has worked at the Milan consulate site for more than two years.”““We have never encountered a labor-exploitation system on this scale,” Radogna said.” Read at Arab News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Carries the AP report with a headline stressing the workers were mostly Indian and the settlement was a record.
- Emphasis
- Settlement figures, worker nationality, prosecutors' allegations and Caddell's non-admission of liability.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the union's account of being denied site access and the labor lawyer's comments on locating workers abroad that appear in the Arab News copy.
- For example
-
“Workers, mostly Indian, building US consulate in Milan agree to record settlement” — South China Morning Post
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Carries the AP report with a headline emphasising workers allegedly exploited and a record payout.
- Emphasis
- The same settlement facts plus union voices on the scale of exploitation and workers' lost dignity.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No significant omissions relative to the AP copy.
What every side reports
- Workers signed settlement deals averaging €45,000 each at a Milan hotel on Wednesday.
- The settlement with Caddell Construction totals €31 million and is described by prosecutors as the largest for labor exploitation in Europe.
- Caddell's document states the settlement is not an admission of liability.
- The investigation remains open and two managers remain under house arrest.
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
South China Morning PostN · · via AP
Workers, mostly Indian, building US consulate in Milan agree to record settlement
Neutral AP copy run by SCMP in British spelling, slightly shorter, emphasising the record settlement for mostly Indian workers.

Right1 article
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AP
Workers allegedly exploited while building US consulate in Milan sign deals for record payout
Neutral AP copy run in full by Arab News, including union comments and the effort to locate workers abroad; framed around alleged exploitation and a record payout.

- 7 Oct 22:59 First Arab NewsRC Workers allegedly exploited while building US consulate in Milan sign deals for record payout via AP
- 8 Oct 03:33 +4h 33m South China Morning PostN Workers, mostly Indian, building US consulate in Milan agree to record settlement via AP
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.