WWI soldier Claude Nuttall's bloodstained diary, found in a tip in 1965, tells a wartime love story
The diary of Australian Cpl Claude Nuttall, killed at the Battle of Amiens in 1918, was found by a boy at a Stourbridge rubbish tip in 1965. Author Colin Read has traced its story in a book launching on 15 October.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2The diary of Australian infantryman Corporal Claude Nuttall, which has a bullet hole and bloodstains, was found in a rubbish tip in Stourbridge, West Midlands, by a boy looking for toys. MetroLC “Corporal Claude Nuttall’s diary – still bearing a bullet hole and blood staining – was found by a young boy rummaging for toys” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “uncovered by chance by a young boy who was rummaging around a rubbish tip in 1965” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 2Both outlets name the boy as 12-year-old Alan Southall and date the find to 1965, 47 years after Nuttall's death. His father read the diary and explained it belonged to an Australian soldier. MetroLC “Alan Southall in a rubbish tip near his home in 1965” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “His dad read it and explained it belonged to an Australian soldier.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 2Nuttall met Violet Palfreyman while recovering from wounds at Wordsley Hospital in Stourbridge, Worcestershire. They married in March 1918 and had five weeks together before he returned to the front in France. MetroLC “They spent just five weeks together before he was sent back to the front line in France.” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “The pair were married two years later in March 1918, and had just five weeks together” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Left · 2A sniper killed him at the Battle of Amiens, three days after his last diary entry on 10 August 1918, which was about three months before Armistice Day. That entry mentions a bombardment, a captured 11¼ inch gun and a letter to 'Vi'. MetroLC “Cpl Nuttall was killed by a sniper at the Battle of Amiens, just three days after his last” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “Started letter to Vi. 11 ¼ inch gun captured by 31st Btn” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 2The diary also records his wedding day, with a ceremony at 12.30pm and photographs at 1.15pm. Another entry describes King George V presenting him with the Military Medal for rescuing fallen comrades in No Man's Land in 1916. MetroLC “Married 12.30pm, all went well. Photos taken 1.15pm. Wedding breakfast 3pm.” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “King George V presenting him with the military medal for rescuing fallen comrades in No Man's Land in 1916” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 2Military records show he enlisted in the Australian Army after his 20th birthday in 1915 and was first sent to Egypt with the 23rd Battalion. Heavy losses on the Western Front then took him to France. He was one of around 8,000 Australian soldiers who married English women during the war. MetroLC “He was initially deployed to Egypt with the 23rd Battalion but heavy losses on the Western Front saw him sent to France.” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “Claude was one of around 8,000 Australian soldiers who married English women while deployed in the war.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Left · 2The diary was kept by Violet's son and husband after she died. It later reached author Colin Read, 69, who spent years tracing Nuttall's family through adverts in local papers. Read says Violet married again five or six years after Nuttall's death, emigrated to New Zealand, came back, and died of complications during childbirth. Daily MirrorL “It had been kept safe by Violet's son and husband in the years after her death.”“I put adverts out in local papers and slowly but surely I started getting some responses.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ MetroLC “died of complications during childbirth.” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 2Read's book, The Digger's Diary, will be launched at Stourbridge Library on 15 October at the Dudley History Festival. Nuttall is commemorated each year by villagers on the Somme. MetroLC “will be launched at Stourbridge Library on October 15 at the Dudley History Festival.” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “Claude Nuttall is now commemorated on the Somme by the local people of the village every year.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 1The Mirror adds context on Amiens. It describes the battle as the opening of the Allied offensive, with up to 100,000 soldiers pushing the German Second Army back, and says about 10,000 Allied soldiers died. It also says the diary's damage is believed to come from a wound that put him in hospital in the UK. Daily MirrorL “The Corporal was one of approximately 10,000 allied soldiers who died during the battle”“The damage is believed to have resulted from a wound sustained by the late soldier which left him hospitalised in the UK.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets run a human-interest story built around a 'tragic' wartime romance and the chance find in a rubbish tip. Both rely heavily on author Colin Read's quotes and diary extracts.
- Emphasis
- The bloodstained, bullet-holed diary, the short marriage, and the sniper's bullet days after the last entry. The Mirror adds battle context and figures.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither independently verifies the diary's provenance beyond Read's account. The two differ on the date of Nuttall's hospital stay, and neither flags this.
- Charged language
- “tragic love story”“incredible love story”“heartbreaking, century-old love story”
- For example
-
“A First World War soldier’s tragic love story has been uncovered after his diary was discovered in a rubbish dump.” — Metro
“has revealed a heartbreaking, century-old love story” — Daily Mirror
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The diary was found in 1965 by 12-year-old Alan Southall in a rubbish tip near Stourbridge.
- Cpl Claude Nuttall was an Australian soldier who married Violet Palfreyman in March 1918.
- He was killed by a sniper at the Battle of Amiens, three days after his last diary entry on 10 August 1918.
- Author Colin Read has written a book, The Digger's Diary, launching at Stourbridge Library on 15 October.
Where accounts differ
-
When Nuttall was in Wordsley Hospital and how long before the wedding
- Left
- Metro says he met Violet while recovering from gunshot wounds and married her in March 1918, quoting Read that he was wounded at the end of the Somme. The Mirror says he was in hospital in 1916 and married two years later.
-
Time between the wedding and his death
- Left
- Metro says five weeks together before he returned to the front, and that he was killed three months before Armistice Day. The Mirror says he was killed five months after marrying.
Claude Nuttall person
Nuttall is presented through his diary as a decorated soldier and newlywed. The coverage says he won the Military Medal and was killed by a sniper after five weeks of marriage.
“decorated by the King in person for saving comrades in front of German trenches.” — Metro
“He was sadly killed five months after he tied the knot with Mrs Palfreyman by a sniper” — Daily Mirror
Left2 articles
-
MetroLC ·
World War I soldier’s diary found at the dump reveals incredible love story
Sympathetic Metro tells the story as an 'incredible' romance cut short, quoting Read at length and with photo credits to SWNS.

-
Sympathetic The Mirror stresses the heartbreak of the story and adds Amiens battle context. It covers the same material and quotes as Metro.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 13 Oct 11:35 First MetroLC World War I soldier’s diary found at the dump reveals incredible love story
- 13 Oct 12:44 +1h 8m Daily MirrorL WW1 soldier's tragic love story told over 100 years later after bloodstained diary found in rubbish tip
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…