Skip to content
Bramble

Entertainment · Celebrity Traitors series 2

Celebrity Traitors episode ends mid round table with Richard E Grant under suspicion

The second episode of the BBC's Celebrity Traitors ended on Friday night before the first round table vote, leaving Richard E Grant's fate unresolved until next week. Viewers complained about the cliffhanger.

4 outlets · 1L · 1C · 2R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 3). New coverage since the last version from Radio Times.

Image: Daily Mail
Image: Radio Times
Image: The Independent
Image: Irish Independent

1 / 4

The story, neutrally told

Right · 2The second episode of the BBC's Celebrity Traitors, shown on Friday night, ended abruptly in the middle of the first round table, before the players wrote their votes on chalk boards. Right · 1The players were debating whether actor Richard E Grant is a Faithful after, in the launch episode, Grant told fellow contestant Joe Lycett that they were a Traitor. The Daily Mail called this the biggest slip-up in the show's history. Right · 1Host Claudia Winkleman cut the debate short with the line 'Players the time for talk is over'. Viewers must wait six days for the next episode to see the outcome.

Right · 2Earlier in the episode, former Today programme host Amol Rajan was murdered by Grant and Maya Jama and became the first player eliminated. Podcaster James Acaster had been the other candidate to be recruited as the third Traitor, and was chosen. Right · 1Rajan said afterwards that they were 'grieving' being out so early, calling it 'gutting to be the first out'. Left · 1In a newsletter, Rajan said Grant told him he had eliminated him 'to protect myself', adding 'I think I just went mad'. Host Claudia Winkleman put Grant's blunder down to 'giddiness' at being picked as a Traitor, saying 'He was just so happy. He just couldn't believe it.'

Left · 1Celia Imrie, who finished seventh in the first celebrity series, told The Times that Grant rang her before filming. She said she warned him the game is 'very strict' and 'it's hard always being on'. Centre · 1Radio Times reported that Imrie's warning came when Grant phoned to ask what the show was like, and that Grant later told The One Show it had been accurate, citing 'the cruelty of people who you instinctively want to trust' once suspicion falls on you. Centre · 1Executive producer Sarah Fay told press including Radio Times that the slip was unprecedented, saying 'within five minutes of being out of the roundtable, he'd already mucked up!'. Radio Times said most fellow celebrities assumed Grant was joking or bluffing, so he was not instantly exposed.

Right · 1At the round table, Julie Hesmondhalgh said the Faithfuls risked being 'the most idiotic group of Faithfuls in the world' if they voted for someone else. Romesh Ranganathan said Grant had 'forced our hand'. Right · 1Viewers criticised the format change on X, with one saying the show had never before ended ahead of a round table vote. Others said they feared losing Grant, who they found entertaining. Right · 1The Daily Mail reported that the series opener on Thursday drew a record nine million peak viewers, averaging 8.9 million overnight, before iPlayer viewing is counted. It said the premiere beat last year's celebrity series opener, which peaked at 6.5 million.

Right · 1The series is filmed at Ardross Castle in the Highlands, with up to £100,000 for the winner's chosen charity. Right · 1The Irish Independent reported that the Friday challenge, in which players were buried in graves in pairs, added £5,000 to the prize pot, bringing it to £20,000. It said Jerry Hall shouted 'haggis' to be dug up, leaving her and Hannah Fry up for murder. It also gave the launch episode's average audience as 8.9 million, peaking at 9.1 million. Left · 1With Grant, Jama and the newly recruited Acaster, the Traitors must now try to kill the remaining 17 Faithfuls without being detected. The show returns on Thursday at 8pm on BBC One.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
The Independent follows up with a human-interest piece on Grant's blunder, built on Celia Imrie's and Amol Rajan's accounts and Claudia Winkleman's explanation, rather than the cliffhanger.
Emphasis
Grant's explanation to Rajan, Imrie's advice and Winkleman's 'giddiness' comment.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the mid-round-table ending or viewer anger about it.
For example
“‘Calendar Girls’ star came seventh in the inaugural A-list edition of the BBC series” — The Independent

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Radio Times runs an entertainment follow-up on Celia Imrie's advice to Grant before filming, drawing on The Times, The One Show and producer comments, rather than the cliffhanger ending.
Emphasis
Imrie's warning that the game is 'very strict', Grant's slip, executive producer Sarah Fay's reaction and Rajan's account of Grant's reasoning.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the mid-round-table ending or viewer anger about it.
Charged language
“now-infamous”“jaw-dropping”
For example
“cautioning him that the BBC game is "very strict" and that "it's hard always being on"” — Radio Times

Right2 outlets

Framing
Both outlets lead on the cliffhanger ending. The Daily Mail stresses viewer anger and Grant's exposure, while the Irish Independent headline summarises the episode's events and gives the challenge detail.
Emphasis
Viewer reaction on X, Grant's slip-up, Rajan's elimination, the graves challenge and record ratings.
Leaves out or plays down
Neither outlet reports comment from the BBC or the production on the decision to end the episode there.
For example
“Celebrity Traitors fans were left furious over the 'ridiculous' cliffhanger ending on Friday night as the hit BBC show abruptly ended mid round table.” — Daily Mail
“Celebrity Traitors ends on cliffhanger after first murder and one new traitor” — Irish Independent

Ask about this story

Loading…