Skip to content
Bramble

US

Christa Pike conscious and speaking in hospital after failed Tennessee execution, lawyers say

Christa Pike, 50, who survived a failed lethal injection in Tennessee on 30 September, is conscious, speaking and still receiving critical care, her attorneys said on Tuesday. Her lawyers call the recovery "medically unprecedented" and say her prognosis is unclear.

19 outlets · 8L · 5C · 6R First reported Account updated
Image: GB News
Image: BBC News
Image: NBC News
Image: Just the News
Image: Newsweek
Image: Daily Mirror
Image: South China Morning Post
Image: ABC News (Australia)

1 / 8

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Christa Pike, 50, is conscious and speaking in hospital nearly a week after a failed execution in Tennessee, her attorneys said in a statement on Tuesday 6 October. Mixed · 2The statement said: "Against all odds, Christa Pike is conscious, speaking, and continues to receive critical medical care." It added that her recovery is "medically unprecedented", her prognosis "remains unclear" and that "at a minimum, we expect a long recovery". Left · 1The lawyers said she suffered severe damage to her arms and remains handcuffed and shackled to her bed. They thanked first responders and the hospital team "who treated Christa like a human", and thanked thousands of people worldwide who sent messages of support.

Left · 3Pike survived two doses of the drug pentobarbital at the attempted execution on 30 September, which followed a struggle to establish intravenous access, according to the Daily Mirror. She was taken by ambulance from a Nashville prison to a hospital and was temporarily on a ventilator. Mixed · 2She had been due to be the first woman executed in Tennessee in more than 200 years. The New York Post says she now appears to be the first person to survive an execution in the US. Left · 1Pike was convicted of the 1995 torture and murder of classmate Colleen Slemmer, committed when Pike was 18 with her boyfriend. The execution was delayed more than eight hours as the US Supreme Court overturned a federal appeals court order that would have halted it so judges could review whether her jury should have heard about alleged childhood sexual abuse.

Left · 1Days earlier, on Sunday, her lawyer Stephen Ferrell told CNN she was on a ventilator and critically ill, and that he was not aware she had regained consciousness. Left · 1Open questions remain. The Daily Mirror reports that Tennessee has not said whether it will try to execute her again, and that no information has been shared about her mental or neurological condition. It notes that US law bars executing a legally incompetent prisoner. It also reports an allegedly leaked image said to show serious damage to her arm.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left8 outlets

Framing
Leads on the lawyers' statement and the 'unprecedented' recovery, with sympathetic detail on her injuries and shackling; the longer pieces add legal context.
Emphasis
Arm damage, shackling, the thanks to medical staff, and (Mirror, Independent) the legal and background context.
Leaves out or plays down
Less detail on the crime in the shorter pieces (Metro, ABC).
Charged language
“botched”“Against all odds”“medically unprecedented”“Death row killer”
For example
“Christa Pike is conscious and speaking nearly a week after a botched execution left her critically injured and temporarily on a ventilator” — ABC News
“Death row killer Christa Pike is awake and speaking as she receives treatment at a hospital” — Daily Mirror

Centre5 outlets

Framing
Brief, straight reports of the lawyers' statement, using 'failed' rather than 'botched'.
Emphasis
The statement, her conviction for Slemmer's murder, and the earlier reports that she was unconscious.
Leaves out or plays down
No account of the injuries beyond handcuffing, or of the legal questions ahead.
Charged language
“failed execution”
For example
“She was sentenced to death following her conviction for murdering Colleen Slemmer in 1995.” — BBC News
“is awake and speaking in a hospital as she continues to receive critical medical care, according to her attorneys.” — Newsweek

Right6 outlets

Framing
Short breaking items that stress the conviction and the unprecedented nature of surviving an execution.
Emphasis
The 1995 'torture and murder' and that she may be the first to survive a US execution.
Leaves out or plays down
Omit the statement's thanks to medical staff and the legal-competence context.
Charged language
“botched execution attempt”“convicted murderer”“torture and murder”
For example
“The convicted murderer, 50, was due to become the first woman put to death in Tennessee in over 200 years” — New York Post
“Pike, who is convicted for the 1995 torture and murder of Colleen Slemmer” — GB News