Skip to content
Bramble

World · South Africa violence against women and government response

Bodies of 11–12 women found in Ekurhuleni since July; Ramaphosa announces new measures

Police have found the bodies of at least 11 women in Ekurhuleni, east of Johannesburg, since July, and have not ruled out a serial killer. President Ramaphosa has announced a women's safety audit and a review of unresolved cases.

2 outlets · 1L · 1C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: The Independent

The story, neutrally told

Police confirmed that three more women's bodies were found in Ekurhuleni, east of Johannesburg, between Saturday and Monday morning. The BBC put the total found there in two months at 12. The Independent counts at least 11 women killed since July, with the 11th body found on Sunday. Police say they cannot rule out a serial killer, but the cases are not confirmed to be linked. The BBC says arrests have been made in three cases that do not appear to be related to the others.

The BBC lists individual cases. Many victims were found partly or fully undressed and bruised, several in Kempton Park. Some cases involve suspects, including a partner, two women charged over one killing, and a man arrested over another. Ramaphosa called the killings a "stain on our national conscience". In an address on Tuesday he announced a women's safety audit within 60 days and a review of unresolved gender-based violence cases within 90 days. Ramaphosa said four suspects have been arrested and that police have collected forensic material. He also said a high-level investigating team has been assigned to the case.

The BBC reports a police task team and a 400,000 rand reward for information leading to arrests. Both outlets place the killings against South Africa's high level of violence. Both cite 5,427 murders, though the BBC dates this to April–June and The Independent to April–July. The BBC adds that the Human Rights Commission counted 569 women killed in April–June.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left1 outlet

Framing
Leads on the serial killer fears and on Ramaphosa's policy response to gender-based violence.
Emphasis
The audit and case-review deadlines, the femicide rate and Ramaphosa's quotes about the burden on women.
Leaves out or plays down
Omits the victim-by-victim detail, the separate arrests in individual cases and the reward.
Charged language
“serial killer fears”
For example
“Ekurhuleni remains on high alert while authorities investigate whether a serial killer or killers are responsible” — The Independent
“We have placed the burden of male violence on women” — The Independent

Centre1 outlet

Framing
An explainer-style timeline of each body found, with what is known about arrests, and the police response.
Emphasis
Individual victims, dates, arrests and the fact that some cases appear unrelated.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention Ramaphosa's audit and case-review measures.
Charged language
“grim discovery”“grisly murder”“stain on our national conscience”
For example
“Nevertheless, police have said they cannot rule out the possibility of a serial killer.” — BBC News
“It was the discovery of her body that really raised the alarm about the spate of killings.” — BBC News

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.